Idaho murders: Killer might have sustained 'bruises or cuts’ that can lead to their capture, says expert

Giacalone also asserted that a reward announcement could help crack the case that has shocked the entire country. He told Fox News Digital, “The idea behind the reward is putting it out initially because you're looking for somebody specific, who came home for the holidays and who might have had some bruises or cuts or some other thing. The uncle who doesn't like everybody is sitting at the Thanksgiving table and looking at the kid saying, ‘Something’s wrong here.’”

However, police spokeswoman Robbie Johnson defended the cops' decision to not announce a reward for tips. "Investigators continue to get good tips and leads and are focusing on those at this time," Johnson said.

This comes as an unofficial theory about a “white 2011-13 Hyundai Elantra” that was supposedly near the house when the killings were carried out has been doing the rounds on the internet. A Reddit post implied that “out-of-towners” who came to see a football game between the Idaho Vandals and UC Davis Aggies on November 12 may have murdered the four youngsters.

The post read, “The ​​football team from UC Davis would have brought plenty of outsiders from out-of-town, either from California or folks from Idaho or Washington who had ties to Northern California or UC Davis, like former alta matter or people who grew up near Davis/Sacramento…Has there been any local speculation as to that being who might have driven the white Hyundai Elantra and/or murdered the four? It's not like it would take much reconnaissance for an out-of-towner to figure out where frat row in Moscow was located, or what off-campus housing would appear as having all-female residents.”

The post added, “...Or if the perpetrator had ties to The University of Idaho in Moscow, maybe he already knew that information and happened to be in town, with the desire to kill. Hell, it's not like murderers don't play sports, either. Dipping into a town for a day or two, knowing you'll be long gone from the area, probably opens up a world of possibilities for the murderous mind.”

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.